By Dr. Maddie Swannack and Dr. Ben Appleby
Next Lesson - Beliefs of the Public
Contents
Abstract
- The WHO defines health as a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being, and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity.
- There are numerous links between deprivation and ill health, and many different explanations have been proposed for these links.
- There are two common models of health. The biomedical model focuses on physical illness only. The biopsychosocial model looks at the biological, psychological and social aspects of the patient.
- There are drastic differences between the health of the deprived and the more affluent.
- Living with chronic illness is associated with several types of ‘work’ that affect the lives of the patients.
- Many factors influence behaviour. The COM-B model organises them into three conditions: capability, opportunity and motivation.
- Differing treatment models can be applied to substance misuse. Using them helps to explain why different treatments are used.
Core
The World Health Organisation (WHO) defines health as 'a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity'. (source; old address)
This means that to be ‘healthy’, one should be well physically, mentally and socially.
There are three ways to interpret this definition of health. They matter because they shape how a patient (especially one with a chronic illness) sees themselves and their health.
- Positive - a state of well-being and fitness.
- Functional - the ability to perform the tasks needed.
- Negative - the absence of illness.
Chronic illness is a long-term condition that cannot currently be cured, but can often be managed with medication or other treatment. It can have a significant impact on the person living with it. Symptoms may vary from day to day. Some people also have comorbidities (other health conditions alongside the chronic illness). Living with a chronic condition can have a profound effect on social interaction, mental health and general day-to-day life.
There are numerous studies that have shown a link between deprivation (or poverty) and ill health. There are many theories as to why this is. The Black Report (a UK government report published in 1980) put forward four explanations for health inequalities: artefact, social selection, behavioural and material. The psychosocial explanation below came from later research.
- Social Selection - this theory states that health determines socio-economic status (a person’s income, education and job position). If a patient is chronically ill, they may be less able to work. This can increase the chances of them entering poverty or having a lower socio-economic status.
- Behavioural - patients in deprived areas are more likely to engage in behaviours damaging to health (negative health behaviours), like smoking. They also take part in fewer positive health behaviours, such as a good diet and regular exercise. Alcohol is more complicated: at similar levels of drinking, people in deprived areas have more alcohol-related ill health than people in richer areas.
- Psychosocial - the stress of working in poorly paid, poor quality, low skilled/status jobs can cause biological changes, and this can lead to poor health.
- Material - the direct effects of poverty such as poor access to food or poor access to quality housing.
- Artefact - this theory says that poverty and poor health are not truly linked. The apparent link is a by-product of the methods used to measure health and deprivation.
It has been theorised that the largest cause for increases in life expectancy in the UK in the last 100 years, is likely due to social improvements such as improved housing conditions, sanitation and diet rather than medical advances.
There are two prevailing models of health: The Biomedical Model and The Biopsychosocial Model. The biomedical model sees illness as a physical fault in the body that doctors diagnose and treat. The biopsychosocial model (biological, psychological and social) says that health also depends on a person’s thoughts, feelings and social circumstances. Both are compared in the table below.

Table - The differences between the Biomedical Model and the Biopsychosocial Model
SimpleMed original by Dr. Maddie Swannack
A 2019 report by the King’s Fund states:
‘In 2015-17, males living in the least deprived 10 per cent of areas in England could expect to live almost a decade (9.3 years) longer than males living in the 10 per cent most deprived areas, and for females the gap was 7.5 years. Much of this inequality is caused by higher mortality from heart and respiratory disease, and lung cancer, in more deprived areas.’
More recent figures from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) show that the gap has not closed. Life expectancy at birth is the average number of years a newborn is expected to live. In 2022 to 2024 it was 73.2 years for males and 78.3 years for females in the most deprived areas of England. In the least deprived areas it was 83.6 years for males and 86.4 years for females. The difference is about 10 years for males and 8 years for females. The ONS reports that this inequality is larger than before the COVID-19 pandemic (2017 to 2019), by 0.9 years for males and 0.5 years for females.
The causes of health inequalities are debated. The explanations in the Deprivation and Health section above are the ones usually discussed.
An important theory to be familiar with is the Inverse Care Law, described by Julian Tudor Hart in 1971. It says that the availability of good medical care tends to vary inversely with the need of the population served (the more a population needs care, the less good care is available to it). In other words, the people who need care most are the least likely to receive it. People who need care least tend to use health services more.
Living with Chronic Conditions
Living with chronic illness can be very hard work. Corbin and Strauss described three types of ‘work’ that people living with chronic illness have to expend: illness work, everyday life work and biographical work. This list also includes emotional work, which is not one of their three:
- Illness Work - this is the day to day effort of managing symptoms and dealing with things like medications.
- ‘Everyday Life’ Work - this is the effort of going about day to day tasks, like walking or preparing food and the adjustments required to routine to facilitate these tasks.
- Emotional Work - this is the effort that it takes every day to overcome the emotionally draining effects of the illness. This also involves the impact on the emotions of those around the patient.
- Biographical Work - when suffering with a chronic illness, a patient can feel as though they have lost their identity for various reasons. This is the work that goes into reassessing and re-establishing a new or different sense of self.
Individuals with chronic conditions can also be the victims of stigma. Stigma can be described using four terms from two frameworks: discreditable and discredited status (Goffman), and enacted and felt stigma (Scambler and Hopkins):
- Discreditable status - a potentially stigmatising characteristic is not already known or immediately apparent to others and may be concealed.
- Discredited status - a potentially stigmatising characteristic is already known or apparent to others. A condition can be non-visible yet known, for example after disclosure. These two terms describe only whether others know about the condition. They do not say whether discrimination has happened or is feared.
- Enacted stigma - the real direct experience of prejudice and discrimination as a result of illness.
- Felt stigma - the fear of experiencing stigma, shame or abuse. This can lead patients to conceal their condition from others.
Health-related behaviours are actions that either promote good health or lead to illness. This means that both smoking and exercise count as a health-related behaviour, even though they lead to different outcomes.
Classical conditioning
Classical conditioning was first explored in the work of Ivan Pavlov, where one stimulus (anything that triggers a response) becomes paired with another. Pavlov famously explored this phenomenon with dogs. Food made the dogs salivate. Pavlov rang a bell each time the food was given. After many repetitions, the dogs began to associate the sound of the bell with food, so they began to salivate when they heard the bell, even without food. This can be seen in addictive behaviours. For example if an ex-smoker used to smoke after lunch whilst at work they may crave a cigarette after lunch as they have come to associate lunch with cigarettes. These cravings can be a very tricky hurdle in combatting any addiction and can trigger relapse.
Operant conditioning
In operant conditioning, behaviour is learnt through its consequences. A behaviour followed by a reward (reinforcement) becomes more likely. A behaviour followed by an unpleasant outcome becomes less likely. For example, a young child who burns their hand on a hot stove learns that touching it is a bad idea and will not do it again. This cycle of action, consequence and change in future behaviour is also applicable in addiction. Many unhealthy behaviours are immediately rewarding. For example if a patient uses illicit drugs the positive high they get from the use of the drug will encourage further use. The unpleasant effects of withdrawal strengthen this further, because they make stopping harder. This can lead to addiction and dependency.
Social Learning Theory
People learn through observed behaviours and seek to copy these behaviours to gain the same praise. (Put simply, people copy behaviours they observe in others.) For example, if an individual sees others drinking alcohol and having fun, they may copy this behaviour to have fun too.
Peer pressure can add to this. If a group accepts that drinking alcohol is necessary to have fun, an outsider who wants to be accepted may drink alcohol to fit in and gain praise.
However, these theories can sound deterministic (as if behaviour is fixed by past learning). Taken literally, they would mean that no one could ever escape a bad habit, and that the people in the examples could never recover. This cannot be true. People do break these patterns, although it can be difficult and may take several attempts and a lot of effort. So these three theories do not fully explain behaviour on their own.
The COM-B model (Capability, Opportunity, Motivation and Behaviour) describes the factors that contribute to a behaviour. Take for example a patient who is diagnosed with Type 1 Diabetes Mellitus and is now required to inject insulin before a meal.
This patient must have the capability to perform the injections. This means that they must understand the process of how to safely inject insulin and have the ability to do so.
They must also have the opportunity to do so, through having insulin available and the time to perform the injections before each meal.
Capability and opportunity both influence the patient’s motivation to inject. The patient must also want to inject: they need to understand why the injections matter, and what could happen if they choose not to have them.
Capability, opportunity and motivation all contribute to the patient’s behaviour, including whether they choose to inject.

Diagram - The COM-B Model
SimpleMed original by Dr. Maddie Swannack
Applying Models to Substance Misuse
It is possible to apply different treatment models to substance misuse. Here, substance misuse means IV drug use or harmful alcohol use, so that specific treatment examples can be given. These models can be applied to any form of addiction.
There are three main treatment models when considering substance misuse:
- Medical - this model treats the physical symptoms of addiction with pharmacological interventions (drug treatments). Some of these drugs treat the dependence itself, as in Relapse Prevention below. The model can also involve managing withdrawal symptoms and treating vitamin deficiency (thiamine (vitamin B1) and folate (vitamin B9) are often low in people who are alcohol dependent). For dependence on prescribed painkillers, it can involve reducing the dose slowly (tapering).
- Disease - this model sees addiction as an illness with a strong biological component and ‘loss of control’ as a central feature. It views avoidance (staying away from alcohol or drugs completely, also called abstinence) as a key treatment approach. This model uses programmes like the 12 Step programme (the approach used by Alcoholics Anonymous) for alcohol dependence to put avoidance tactics in place. NICE advises giving everyone seeking help for alcohol misuse information about self-help groups such as Alcoholics Anonymous, but the main NICE recommendations for treatment are psychological therapies and medicines.
- Behavioural - this model views addiction not as a disease, but a series of poorly learned behaviours that form a negative coping mechanism. This means that treatment focuses on the past experiences that have encouraged this behaviour, and on teaching more positive coping mechanisms.
In practice, treatment often combines the models. For example, NICE advises considering medicines together with a psychological (talking) therapy for people with moderate or severe alcohol dependence after a successful withdrawal. A person who injects drugs may likewise need medical treatment for the symptoms of withdrawal. They may also need help to avoid situations where they might be exposed to drugs, and counselling to teach alternative coping mechanisms.
There are also two approaches that sit alongside the three treatment models. Which one is used depends on whether the patient wants to change.
- Harm Reduction - this occurs to maintain the health of the patient while they work towards being able to combat their addiction. The measures below can also be offered alongside other treatment, where they suit the person’s needs, to help reduce the lasting damage of addiction.
- Alcohol dependence - thiamine (vitamin B1) supplements are offered to some harmful or dependent drinkers, such as those who are malnourished, have decompensated liver disease (liver disease with complications such as jaundice or fluid build-up in the abdomen) or are in acute withdrawal. This helps prevent Wernicke’s encephalopathy, a serious brain condition caused by thiamine deficiency.
- Opioids (drugs such as heroin and morphine, also called opiates) - naloxone is the emergency antidote for opioid overdose. It reverses the slowed or stopped breathing that makes an overdose life-threatening. It has a short duration of action, so repeat doses may be needed, and the person still needs an ambulance (call 999). Drug services can also supply take-home naloxone, so that people at risk and those around them can use it in an emergency (see Pharmacology unit).
- For those injecting drugs - needle and syringe programmes (needle exchanges) and testing for blood-borne viruses (including HIV and hepatitis B and C). Needle and syringe programmes encourage safer injecting practice and help to reduce both the sharing of needles and the spread of blood-borne infections.
- Relapse Prevention - this is for patients who are willing to change but need a helping hand to avoid slipping back into their addiction.
- Disulfiram - a medicine that deters drinking, because alcohol then causes an unpleasant reaction. This can include flushing, nausea, palpitations (a pounding or racing heartbeat) and, more seriously, abnormal heart rhythms (arrhythmias), low blood pressure and collapse. For people with moderate or severe alcohol dependence, NICE suggests considering acamprosate or oral naltrexone (medicines that help people stay off alcohol) first, after a successful withdrawal and together with a psychological intervention. Disulfiram is for people who want to stay off alcohol completely but cannot take those medicines, or who prefer disulfiram and understand its risks. (For more information, check out the Metabolism unit, especially the article on Alcohol Metabolism).
- Methadone (an opioid taken as a daily substitute for heroin) - used to treat opioid dependence. The dose is adjusted until there are no signs of withdrawal, and it can later be reduced slowly and accurately. NICE recommends methadone and buprenorphine (a similar opioid substitute) as options for maintenance therapy (long-term treatment that keeps the person stable).
Reviewed by: Dr. Thomas Burnell and Dr. Marcus Judge
Quiz
- 67507


