By Dr. Marcus Judge

Next Lesson - Prostate Pathology

Urinary System


Contents

Abstract

  • Urinary tract infection (UTI) is the presence of bacteria multiplying in the urine with associated symptoms or signs of infection. It is one of the most common conditions seen in primary care.
  • UTIs are classified in two ways. The anatomical axis separates lower UTI, or cystitis (infection of the bladder and urethra), from upper UTI, or pyelonephritis (infection of the kidney). The clinical axis separates uncomplicated from complicated UTI. The uncomplicated vs complicated distinction matters more for treatment than the lower vs upper one.
  • Escherichia coli (a bowel bacterium) is identified in up to 77% of UTIs seen in primary care. It ascends through the urethra from the perineal flora (the bacteria living on the skin between the anus and the genitals). The shorter female urethra explains the marked female predominance, as does the closeness of its opening (the meatus) to the vaginal entrance (the introitus) and the anus.
  • Uncomplicated cystitis is treated with a 3-day course of oral antibiotics. Nitrofurantoin is a first choice if kidney function is adequate (eGFR, the estimated glomerular filtration rate, is 45 mL/min or more). Trimethoprim is the other first choice, if there is a low risk of resistance. Pyelonephritis (kidney infection) needs a longer course, most often 7 to 10 days of oral cefalexin. Intravenous antibiotics are reserved for severe or septic cases, per local guidance. The choices include a cephalosporin (a class of antibiotic related to penicillin) or gentamicin, and co-amoxiclav only in combination with another antibiotic or when the culture result shows it will work. Pregnancy, children and catheter-associated infections need special consideration.

Core

Introduction

The bladder is normally sterile. Urine is the by-product of glomerular filtration (the kidney filtering the blood) and tubular handling (reabsorption and secretion along the nephron). It is stored briefly before voiding (passing urine). Bacteria can colonise the urinary tract (live in it, without necessarily causing symptoms) by ascending the urethra. This is the dominant route in adults. Much less commonly, bacteria arrive by haematogenous seeding (spread through the blood). Blood-borne spread is the dominant route in newborn babies (neonates) and for unusual organisms such as Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Candida (a yeast). When bacteria do colonise, the result ranges from asymptomatic bacteriuria (bacteria in the urine without symptoms) to a self-limiting cystitis (one that clears by itself). At the severe end is pyelonephritis (kidney infection) with sepsis.

UTI is one of the most common reasons for antibiotic prescription in the UK, and consequently a major driver of antibiotic resistance. The principles of antibiotic treatment (antibacterial chemotherapy) are covered in Antibiotics and Antibiotics (Infection); the relevant anatomy is in Anatomy of the Kidneys, Bladder and Urethra.

Definitions and Classification

Several overlapping terms are used. The pre-clinical core is:

  • Bacteriuria: bacteria in the urine. Significant bacteriuria is conventionally ≥ 105 colony-forming units per mL (viable bacteria that grow into colonies on a culture plate) on a midstream sample (urine caught mid-flow). Lower counts can be significant in symptomatic patients or with fastidious organisms (organisms that are hard to grow in culture).
  • Asymptomatic bacteriuria: significant bacteriuria with no urinary symptoms. Most cases require no treatment; the exceptions (pregnancy and pre-urological surgery) are the points worth memorising.
  • Lower UTI (cystitis): symptomatic infection limited to the bladder and urethra.
  • Upper UTI (pyelonephritis): symptomatic infection of the kidney and renal pelvis.
  • Urethritis: isolated infection of the urethra. Most cases of urethritis are sexually transmitted (gonococcal or chlamydial, meaning caused by gonorrhoea or chlamydia) and are dealt with separately as reproductive tract infections.

The clinically more useful axis is uncomplicated vs complicated:

  • Uncomplicated UTI: in a non-pregnant woman with a structurally and functionally normal urinary tract. This group has the most predictable microbiology and the shortest treatment courses.
  • Complicated UTI: UTI in any of these situations:
    • a structural or functional abnormality of the urinary tract, such as stones, obstruction, vesico-ureteric reflux (urine flowing backwards from the bladder up the ureter), a neurogenic bladder (a bladder with abnormal nerve control) or an indwelling catheter (one left in place in the bladder);
    • pregnancy;
    • infection in men;
    • a weakened immune system (immunocompromise);
    • any other significant long-term illness (comorbidity), such as diabetes or renal impairment (reduced kidney function).

UTI in any man is, by convention, treated as complicated, because the longer male urethra and the prostate make UTI in men intrinsically harder to clear.

Epidemiology and Risk Factors

UTI is common in women. NICE Clinical Knowledge Summaries (CKS, guidance summaries for primary care) say that acute UTI occurs in up to 50% of women. In an England survey, 37% of women reported at least one UTI in their lifetime, and 11% reported a UTI in the past year. Estimates vary with how UTI is defined. Men are largely protected until older age, when prostatic enlargement and urinary stasis (urine stagnating in the bladder) become important.

The major risk factors map closely on to how infection arises (its pathogenesis):

  • Female anatomy: short urethra (about 4 cm in women against 18-20 cm in men), proximity of the urethral opening (meatus) to the vaginal entrance (introitus) and anus.
  • Sexual intercourse: mechanical introduction of perineal flora (bacteria from the skin around the anus and genitals); the so-called "honeymoon cystitis".
  • Contraceptive diaphragm (a vaginal cap) with spermicide (a sperm-killing contraceptive gel): alters the vaginal flora (the normal bacteria of the vagina) and makes colonisation by uropathogenic E. coli more likely. E. coli is a bowel bacterium, and uropathogenic strains are those able to infect the urinary tract.
  • Pregnancy: smooth-muscle relaxation by progesterone and ureteric compression by the pregnant (gravid) uterus produce stasis.
  • Postmenopausal status: oestrogen deficiency thins the vaginal and urethral epithelium and reduces protective lactobacilli (the harmless bacteria that normally dominate the vagina).
  • Diabetes mellitus: glucose in the urine (glycosuria) provides substrate (food for bacteria); damage to the autonomic nerves (autonomic neuropathy) reduces complete bladder emptying.
  • Urinary tract obstruction: stones, prostatic hypertrophy (enlargement of the prostate), narrowings (strictures), tumours; covered in Urinary Tract Obstruction.
  • Indwelling urinary catheter: a biofilm (a sticky layer of bacteria) forms on the catheter surface; the incidence of bacteriuria is 3-8% per day of catheterisation (an extra 3 to 8 in every 100 catheterised people each day).
  • Vesico-ureteric reflux (urine flowing backwards from the bladder up the ureter): the major risk factor for recurrent pyelonephritis and renal scarring in children.
  • Immunocompromise (a weakened immune system) impairs defence against bacteria. It may be caused by drugs (steroids, chemotherapy) or by disease (HIV, or after a transplant).

Microbiology and Pathogenesis

The dominant pathogen by a wide margin is Escherichia coli, which is identified in up to 77% of UTIs seen in primary care (in a 2023 survey of hospital inpatients in England, it made up about 47% of the organisms identified in healthcare-associated UTIs). The remainder of community cases are mostly:

  • Staphylococcus saprophyticus: a recognised cause in young sexually active women, in whom it is the second commonest cause of UTI after E. coli.
  • Klebsiella pneumoniae.
  • Proteus mirabilis: produces urease (an enzyme), which splits urea into ammonia, making the urine more alkaline (alkalinising it) and promoting struvite (magnesium ammonium phosphate) stones. The combination of UTI and a staghorn renal calculus (a large, branching kidney stone) suggests Proteus.
  • Enterococci, particularly in older patients or after instrumentation (procedures that put devices into the urinary tract).

In the catheterised, hospitalised or recently antibiotic-treated patient, the spectrum widens to include Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Serratia. Resistant Enterobacteriaceae (a family of bowel bacteria that includes E. coli) also appear. These produce extended-spectrum beta-lactamases (ESBL), which are enzymes that destroy many penicillin-type antibiotics.

The dominant route of infection is ascending: organisms from the perineum reach the bladder through the urethra, sometimes propelled by sexual activity or instrumentation. E. coli strains causing UTI are generally uropathogenic E. coli (UPEC), distinguished from commensal strains (harmless residents of the bowel) by virulence factors (features that help bacteria cause disease):

  • P-fimbriae (pili): hair-like surface projections that adhere to glycolipid receptors (receptors made of a fat molecule with a sugar attached) on uroepithelium (the epithelium lining the urinary tract); particularly associated with pyelonephritis.
  • Type 1 fimbriae: bind mannose-rich receptors (receptors rich in mannose, a sugar) and mediate attachment to bladder uroepithelium.
  • Haemolysins: damage host tissue.
  • Aerobactin: iron-acquisition system to compete with host transferrin (the blood protein that carries iron).

Host defences include the constant flushing action of urine and the protective mucopolysaccharide layer of the bladder (the glycosaminoglycan or GAG layer, a mucus coat over the bladder lining). They also include urinary IgA (immunoglobulin A, an antibody), low urinary pH, high urea concentration, and tight junctions between the cells of the uroepithelium. Failure of any of these (incomplete emptying, oestrogen deficiency, instrumentation) tilts the balance towards infection.

Clinical Features

Lower UTI (Cystitis)

The classical syndrome is frequency, urgency and dysuria: needing to pass urine often (frequency) and suddenly (urgency), with painful urination (dysuria). There is often suprapubic discomfort (pain above the pubic bone) and cloudy or foul-smelling (malodorous) urine. Visible blood in the urine (haematuria) is reported in roughly a third of women. It can occur with a simple UTI. NICE CKS advises an urgent 2-week-wait urology referral for a woman aged 45 or over whose visible haematuria persists or recurs after successful treatment of the UTI. Symptoms typically come on over hours.

Cystitis is a clinical diagnosis. In an otherwise healthy non-pregnant woman, dysuria and frequency without vaginal symptoms raise the probability of UTI to more than 90%. That figure is a positive predictive value (the chance that the diagnosis is right when these symptoms are present). NICE CKS lists three key symptoms: dysuria, new nocturia (waking at night to pass urine) and cloudy urine. A woman under 65 with two or three of them and no risk factors for complicated UTI does not need a urine dipstick test (a strip dipped in the urine that changes colour to show nitrite, white cells and blood), because UTI is likely. Empirical treatment (treatment started on the likely cause before test results) can then be considered. With only one key symptom, CKS advises a urine dipstick test.

Upper UTI (Pyelonephritis)

The hallmark of pyelonephritis is systemic illness on top of urinary tract symptoms:

  • Fever, rigors (shaking chills), sweats, malaise (feeling generally unwell).
  • Loin (flank) pain, often unilateral, worse on movement, with tenderness elicited at the renal angle, also called the costovertebral angle (between the 12th rib and the lateral border of erector spinae, the muscle beside the spine).
  • Nausea and vomiting.
  • Tachycardia (fast heart rate), hypotension (low blood pressure) if septic.
  • Lower urinary tract symptoms (dysuria, frequency) are usually present but can be absent.

Pyelonephritis can progress to urosepsis (sepsis arising from the urinary tract); any UTI with features of sepsis requires urgent hospital assessment and intravenous antibiotics. Sepsis is covered separately in Sepsis.

Atypical Presentations

Two groups merit special suspicion because UTI presents atypically:

  • Older adults: classical urinary symptoms are less commonly reported. UTI may present as new confusion or delirium, falls, anorexia (loss of appetite), generalised malaise or non-specific decompensation (a general decline in how well the person is coping). UTI is over-diagnosed in this group: a positive urine dipstick alone in an asymptomatic catheterised older adult is not a UTI and antibiotics are not indicated. Treat only when there are clinical features of infection.
  • Catheterised patients: bacteriuria is almost universal with a long-term catheter. A dipstick is not used to diagnose infection in these patients. Most positive cultures represent colonisation (bacteria present without causing disease) rather than infection. Antibiotics are reserved for symptomatic cases (pain, sepsis, signs of upper-tract involvement).

Investigations

Investigation should be matched to the clinical picture:

  • Urine dipstick: tests for nitrites and for leukocyte esterase. Nitrites are produced when Gram-negative bacteria (a bacterial group defined by Gram staining) reduce dietary nitrate. The nitrite test is specific but not sensitive: a positive result is likely to be real, but a negative result does not rule infection out. Some organisms, such as S. saprophyticus, enterococci and Pseudomonas, do not produce nitrites. Leukocyte esterase is a surrogate for white cells in the urine. That test is sensitive but not specific: a negative result helps rule infection out, but a positive result can have other causes. The UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) cites an English primary care study of 434 women with at least 2 urinary symptoms and no vaginal discharge. In that study, the positive predictive value (the chance that a positive result is a true UTI) was 92% for a positive nitrite together with either blood or leukocyte esterase. NICE CKS advises a dipstick for a woman under 65 with one key symptom of UTI or other urinary symptoms. A dipstick that is positive for nitrite, or for both leukocyte esterase and red blood cells, makes UTI likely. A dipstick that is negative for nitrite, leukocyte esterase and red blood cells makes UTI less likely. CKS advises against using a dipstick to make the diagnosis in women over 65, in pregnancy, or when a catheter is in place. A urine sample is sent for culture instead. In babies and children aged 3 months to 3 years, NICE advises dipstick testing.
  • Midstream urine (MSU) for microscopy, culture and sensitivity (looking at the urine under a microscope, growing the bacteria, and testing which antibiotics kill them): the most reliable test (the gold standard) for confirming infection and guiding antibiotic choice. Indicated in pregnancy, men, children, treatment failures, complicated UTI, suspected pyelonephritis, recurrent UTI and catheterised patients who have symptoms. In a catheterised patient the sample is taken from the catheter (through the sampling port if there is one, using an aseptic technique, which keeps outside germs out of the sample), before antibiotics are given. If the catheter has been changed, the sample is taken from the new catheter. If it has been removed, a midstream sample is sent instead.
  • Blood tests in pyelonephritis or sepsis: full blood count (to look for a raised white cell count), C-reactive protein (a blood marker of inflammation), urea, creatinine and electrolytes (to check kidney function), blood cultures (to find the organism if bacteria are in the blood) and lactate (a marker of poor blood flow to the tissues, as in septic shock).
  • Imaging in patients with pyelonephritis whose symptoms persist despite 48 to 72 hours of appropriate antibiotics. A renal tract ultrasound is the usual first scan, with CT or MRI if obstruction is suspected or symptoms persist. NICE advises reassessing if symptoms worsen at any time, or have not started to improve within 48 hours of starting the antibiotic. Suspected obstruction by a stone is different and must not wait. With signs of infection or sepsis it is an emergency: the person needs immediate hospital admission and urgent drainage of the kidney (decompression). CT KUB (a low-dose CT of the kidneys, ureters and bladder) is the test of choice for stones. NICE advises it within 24 hours for suspected renal colic (severe pain caused by a stone in the urinary tract), with ultrasound instead in pregnancy. Contrast CT (a CT scan done after an injection of dye, which shows up on the scan) is used for suspected renal or perinephric (around the kidney) abscess.

Special Groups

Pregnancy

Bacteriuria in pregnancy is significant even when asymptomatic, because:

  • It is associated with preterm labour (labour before 37 weeks) and low birth weight.
  • Up to 30% of untreated pregnant women with asymptomatic bacteriuria develop acute pyelonephritis (kidney infection).

The UK National Screening Committee does not recommend population screening (testing all pregnant women, whether or not they have symptoms) for asymptomatic bacteriuria. NICE CKS does advise a midstream urine sample, sent for culture and sensitivity, at the booking appointment (the first antenatal visit) for women with an intermediate or high risk pregnancy, rather than for every pregnant woman. NICE CKS advises antibiotic treatment when asymptomatic bacteriuria is found in pregnancy. Antibiotic choice is constrained by teratogenicity (some drugs can harm the developing baby):

  • Nitrofurantoin: can be used in early pregnancy but is avoided at term (the last few weeks). The risk is haemolytic anaemia (anaemia from red cell breakdown) in the newborn (neonate), through red cells that lack glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD). NICE NG109, the BNF and the CKS nitrofurantoin page all say to avoid it at term. The CKS advice on asymptomatic bacteriuria in pregnancy is stricter: nitrofurantoin is the first choice, but not in the third trimester (the last 3 months).
  • Trimethoprim: NICE CKS advises against prescribing it in pregnancy. The main concern is the first trimester (the first 12 weeks). Trimethoprim is a folate antagonist (it blocks the vitamin folate, which the baby needs to form the spine and brain) and may increase the risk of birth defects, including neural-tube defects (such as spina bifida).
  • Cefalexin and amoxicillin are reasonable alternatives once sensitivities are known.

Children

UTI in children can signal an underlying abnormality of the urinary tract, particularly vesico-ureteric reflux (VUR), in which urine flows backwards from the bladder up the ureter. UK NICE guidance (NG224) recommends a renal tract ultrasound within 6 weeks for any baby under 6 months with a first UTI that responds to treatment. It does not recommend routine ultrasound for older children with a first UTI that responds to treatment, unless the UTI is atypical (for example, the child is seriously ill, has poor urine flow, or does not respond to suitable antibiotics within 48 hours). Further imaging depends on age and on whether the UTI is atypical or recurrent. A DMSA scan (a kidney scan that shows scarring) is done 4 to 6 months after the infection for atypical or recurrent UTI in children under 3 years, and for recurrent UTI in older children. An MCUG (micturating cystourethrogram, an X-ray of the bladder taken while passing urine, to look for VUR) is advised for babies under 6 months with an atypical or recurrent UTI. In children aged 6 months to under 3 years it is not done routinely and is considered only if there is dilatation (widening) of the urinary tract on ultrasound, poor urine flow, a non-E. coli infection or a family history of VUR. It is not part of the schedule for children aged 3 years or older. Babies under 3 months with a suspected UTI are referred immediately to a paediatric specialist (a doctor who specialises in children). Untreated reflux can lead to chronic renal scarring, hypertension and chronic kidney disease.

Catheter-Associated UTI

Indwelling catheters develop a biofilm (a sticky layer of bacteria) within days. The incidence of bacteriuria is approximately 3-8% per day of catheterisation (an extra 3 to 8 in every 100 catheterised people each day). After about a month nearly all people with a catheter have bacteriuria. The clinical decisions are:

  • Do not send routine urine cultures from asymptomatic catheterised patients.
  • Treat only when there are signs of infection (fever, suprapubic pain (pain above the pubic bone), costovertebral angle (renal angle) tenderness, sepsis).
  • If the catheter has been in place for more than 7 days, consider removing it or, if that cannot be done, changing it as part of treatment, since the biofilm shelters bacteria from antibiotics. Do not let catheter removal or change delay antibiotic treatment.

Recurrent UTI

Recurrent UTI is conventionally defined as two or more infections in 6 months or three or more in 12 months. The first task is to distinguish:

  • Relapse: same organism within 2 weeks; suggests inadequate treatment or an anatomical reservoir (a hiding place for bacteria, such as a stone, or prostatitis, which is infection of the prostate).
  • Reinfection: new organism, or same organism > 2 weeks after previous infection; suggests host susceptibility rather than treatment failure.

Investigation in recurrent UTI looks for an anatomical or functional abnormality (post-void residual measurement, which is measuring the urine left in the bladder after passing urine; ultrasound; and sometimes cystoscopy, a camera inspection of the bladder, in older patients).

Principles of Management

Antibiotic choice should be guided by local resistance patterns and the most recent guidance from NICE and the UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA, which replaced Public Health England). The pre-clinical principles are:

Uncomplicated lower UTI in non-pregnant women. First-line UK options (per NICE guideline NG109, on antimicrobial prescribing for lower UTI) are a 3-day course of oral nitrofurantoin or, where there is a low risk of resistance, trimethoprim. Nitrofurantoin concentrates in urine, not tissues. It is therefore unsuitable for pyelonephritis. The BNF (British National Formulary, the UK drug reference) says to avoid it if the eGFR (estimated glomerular filtration rate, a measure of kidney function) is below 45 mL/min. At an eGFR of 30-44, a short course (3 to 7 days) may be used with caution. The short course at an eGFR of 30-44 applies only to uncomplicated lower UTI caused by suspected or proven multidrug-resistant bacteria (bacteria resistant to several antibiotics), and only if the potential benefit outweighs the risk. Trimethoprim has good urinary penetration but rising resistance.

If the first-line agent fails or resistance is high, second-line options include the antibiotics pivmecillinam (a penicillin) or fosfomycin (taken as a single dose), guided by sensitivities (laboratory results showing which antibiotics kill the bacteria).

UTI in men. Always treated as complicated. A 7-day course of nitrofurantoin (if the eGFR is 45 mL/min or more) or trimethoprim is the usual starting point. Nitrofurantoin is not recommended if prostate involvement is suspected, because it is unlikely to reach high enough levels in the prostate to work. Suspected prostatitis requires longer courses with an antibiotic that penetrates the prostate, because most antibiotics do so poorly. Examples are a quinolone (a class of antibiotic that includes ciprofloxacin) or trimethoprim. NICE guideline NG110 (prostatitis) lists ciprofloxacin or ofloxacin (both quinolones) as the first-choice oral antibiotics, with trimethoprim as the alternative if a fluoroquinolone is not appropriate. NG110 also points to the MHRA advice of January 2024 on restrictions and precautions for fluoroquinolones (described below).

Pyelonephritis. Per NICE guideline NG111 (acute pyelonephritis), oral treatment is most often cefalexin (with co-amoxiclav or trimethoprim acceptable only when culture sensitivity supports it). Quinolones such as ciprofloxacin are reserved for cases where first-line options are unsuitable. This follows the restrictions on fluoroquinolone antibiotics (a class that includes ciprofloxacin) set by the MHRA (Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency, the UK medicines regulator), because of the risk of disabling and potentially long-lasting side effects. Septic or vomiting patients require intravenous therapy: typically a cephalosporin, an aminoglycoside (a class of antibiotic) such as gentamicin, or co-amoxiclav (only in combination with another antibiotic, or when the culture result shows susceptibility), chosen per local protocol. The pharmacology of these agents is covered in Antibiotics.

Pregnancy. As above, with first-line agents chosen for safety: nitrofurantoin (avoid at term), cefalexin, amoxicillin (per culture). Avoid trimethoprim (NICE CKS advises against it in pregnancy, mainly because of the first-trimester risk) and avoid quinolones throughout.

Catheter-associated UTI. Treat only symptomatic infection. If the catheter has been in place for more than 7 days, consider removing or changing it, but do not let this delay antibiotics. Choose antibiotics by culture. Broaden empirical cover (antibiotics started before the culture result is known) if previous resistant organisms have been isolated.

Complications

Pre-clinical students should know the main complications of UTI:

  • Urosepsis: pyelonephritis is one of the commonest sources of bacteraemic (with bacteria in the blood) Gram-negative sepsis in UK hospitals.
  • Renal abscess and perinephric abscess: suggested by failure to respond to appropriate antibiotics; require imaging and often percutaneous drainage (drainage through the skin, using a needle or tube).
  • Emphysematous pyelonephritis (emphysematous means gas-containing): a rare necrotising (tissue-destroying) infection with gas-forming organisms, typically in patients with diabetes; carries a substantial mortality.
  • Renal scarring and chronic kidney disease, particularly in children with vesico-ureteric reflux and recurrent pyelonephritis. See Chronic Kidney Disease.
  • Struvite stones: following Proteus or other urease-producing infection; can grow into staghorn calculi (large, branching stones that fill the inner part of the kidney).
  • Pregnancy complications: preterm labour, low birth weight, neonatal sepsis.

Prevention

Prevention strategies for women with recurrent UTI are evidence-graded (supported by differing amounts of evidence); only some are well-supported.

  • Behavioural advice: adequate hydration, voiding (passing urine) after intercourse, wiping front-to-back, avoiding diaphragms (contraceptive caps) coated with spermicide (a chemical that kills sperm). Evidence is modest but the interventions are cheap and risk-free.
  • Topical vaginal oestrogen (a cream, gel, tablet, ring or pessary, a small solid insert) in women around or after the menopause: restores the protective lactobacillus flora (the harmless bacteria that normally live in the vagina). NICE advises considering it for recurrent UTI if behavioural and personal hygiene measures alone are not effective or not appropriate. A 2008 Cochrane review (a systematic summary of the research evidence) found that vaginal oestrogens reduced UTIs in two small studies, but oral oestrogens did not.
  • D-mannose (a sugar): previously suggested as prophylaxis (prevention) because it was thought to interfere with type 1 fimbrial adhesion to bladder uroepithelium. In other words, it was thought to stop bacteria sticking to the lining of the bladder. A large UK placebo-controlled randomised trial published in 2024 (the MERIT trial, in JAMA Internal Medicine) found no reduction in recurrent UTI. Within 6 months, 51.0% of women taking D-mannose and 55.7% of women taking placebo contacted healthcare with a suspected UTI. The authors concluded that D-mannose should not be recommended for prophylaxis in this patient group. NICE NG112 notes that some women may wish to try it (it is a sugar, not a medicine), but NICE CKS advises against recommending D-mannose preparations.
  • Cranberry preparations: widely promoted for many years. A 2023 Cochrane review found that cranberry products probably reduce symptomatic, culture-verified UTIs (confirmed by urine culture) in women with recurrent UTI. It also found that there may be little or no benefit in elderly people living in institutions such as care homes. NICE NG112 says that evidence of benefit is uncertain and that there is no evidence of benefit for older women. NICE CKS advises against recommending over-the-counter cranberry products.
  • Methenamine hippurate: a urinary antiseptic (a substance that kills bacteria in the urine) that releases formaldehyde, a disinfectant chemical, in acidic urine. NICE advises considering it as an alternative to daily antibiotic prophylaxis for recurrent UTI in women. The UK ALTAR trial (240 women, 12 months of treatment) found it non-inferior to daily low-dose antibiotics. Non-inferior means not worse than the comparison by more than a set margin, here one UTI per person-year (one person followed for one year). Symptomatic UTIs treated with antibiotics occurred at 1.38 per person-year with methenamine and 0.89 with antibiotics, a difference inside that margin. During treatment, a smaller proportion of women taking methenamine had antibiotic-resistant E. coli on perineal swabs (56% against 72%). After treatment, a larger proportion of women who had taken methenamine had multidrug-resistant E. coli (20% against 5%). Both resistance differences were borderline for statistical significance (p = 0.05 and p = 0.06). By convention, a p value below 0.05 counts as statistically significant, so these two results sit on the border and could be due to chance.
  • Long-term low-dose antibiotic prophylaxis: NICE NG112 advises considering a trial of a daily antibiotic (for example trimethoprim or nitrofurantoin at night) if there has been no improvement after vaginal oestrogen, single-dose antibiotic prophylaxis or methenamine hippurate, where these were suitable. The person should be told about the risk of resistance with long-term antibiotics and should return for review within 6 months.

Summary

  • UTI is the symptomatic infection of the urinary tract; asymptomatic bacteriuria is generally not treated, except in pregnancy and before urological surgery.
  • The most useful classification is uncomplicated (non-pregnant women, normal tract) versus complicated (everyone else, including all men).
  • E. coli is the dominant pathogen, ascending from the perineum. Staphylococcus saprophyticus, Klebsiella, Proteus (urease, struvite stones) and Enterococcus account for most of the rest in community settings.
  • Cystitis presents with frequency, urgency and dysuria; pyelonephritis adds fever, loin pain and systemic illness. Older adults and catheterised patients present atypically.
  • First-line treatment of uncomplicated cystitis in non-pregnant women is a 3-day course of nitrofurantoin (if the eGFR is 45 mL/min or more) or trimethoprim (if there is a low risk of resistance). Pyelonephritis requires a longer course (oral or IV per NICE NG111, for example 7 to 10 days of oral cefalexin). Imaging should be considered if the patient is not improving, and urgently if an infected, obstructed kidney is suspected.
  • Pregnancy, children, men and catheterised patients all need a different approach. In pregnancy, asymptomatic bacteriuria is treated and some antibiotics are avoided. Babies under 6 months with a first UTI that responds to treatment need an ultrasound. Men have a 7-day course. In catheterised patients, only symptomatic infection is treated. Vesico-ureteric reflux (urine flowing backwards from the bladder up the ureter) is one reason to consider imaging after a paediatric UTI, especially if it is atypical or recurrent.

Reviewed by: Dr. Marcus Judge

Quiz

Preview the Urinary Tract Infections quiz